Update: My ice cream maker wasn't frozen, so I made a batch of this ice cream in the freezer. I poured the mixture into a large plastic bowl then placed it in the freezer. I froze it for 2-3 hours, whisking the mixture thoroughly every 30-45 minutes. Jazlyn absolutely loves this ice cream and said it was still creamy and good. The top 2 pictures are the ice cream made in the maker and the other 3 are the ice cream made in the freezer.
1 box Jell-O instant pudding mix, any safe flavor desired
2 cups soy milk
Add-ins desired such as crumbled cookies, safe chocolate chips, diced brownies, graham crackers, frozen
cookie dough, sprinkles, coconut, etc.
Whisk together the pudding mix and soy milk until the powder is dissolved. Pour the mixture into the ice cream maker along with the add-in you desire. Process according to the manufacturer's directions.
* Serve immediately as a soft-serve ice cream or spoon it into a covered container and place in the fridge until firm set and scoopable.